tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

Our CPA produces clean annual reviews, but our M&A advisor insists we commission a sell-side Quality of Earnings report two years before going to market. Why is standard tax accounting dangerous during due diligence?

A CPA prepares your tax returns and year-end financials with one core objective: legally minimizing your taxable income. An institutional buyer looks at your financial statements with the exact opposite objective: uncovering your true, sustainable, and normalized cash flow.

Standard CPA tax filings and basic reviews are dangerous in an M&A process because they obscure your actual operating performance. They often bundle non-operational expenses, rely on cash-basis timing quirks, and fail to distinguish between one-time project windfalls and repeatable earnings. If you wait for the buyer to perform their own Quality of Earnings audit during exclusivity, their forensic accountants will aggressively reclassify your revenue, disallow your add-backs, and cut your reported EBITDA. That leads to renegotiated purchase prices, escrow holdbacks, or broken deals.

Commissioning a sell-side Quality of Earnings report two years ahead of an exit gives you control over your narrative. A sell-side QofE performs a rigorous forensic examination of your trailing historical data:

- It converts your financial data to strict GAAP accrual standards, matching revenue recognized with the actual cost of delivery.

- It analyzes customer churn, monthly cohort retention, and margin variations across your product lines.

- It establishes thoroughly documented, defensible EBITDA adjustments for owner compensation, discretionary overhead, and non-recurring operational disruptions.

When you identify margin weaknesses or revenue leakage on your own terms, you have time to solve them through your quarterly Rocks. By the time you enter due diligence, your financials are an ironclad asset that defends your valuation rather than a liability that costs you millions at the closing table.

Category: Exit Planning

← All questions