tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

The buyer is using an earnout to bridge a two-million-dollar valuation gap, but they are insisting on calculating the payout based on post-close EBITDA targets. Why is an EBITDA earnout dangerous for a seller, and how should we counter-structure the metric?

Never accept an earnout tied to EBITDA or Net Income if the buyer assumes operational control of your company. EBITDA is the easiest line item on an income statement for an acquirer to manipulate. Once the deal closes, the buyer controls corporate overhead allocations, management fees, shared service chargebacks, executive hiring, and software migrations. They can easily depress post-close EBITDA while growing enterprise value, effectively using your own cash flow to eliminate your earnout.

If you must accept an earnout to bridge a valuation gap, push the measurement metric as high up the income statement as possible. The gold standard is a top-line Revenue earnout paired with a defined Gross Margin percentage collar. A gross margin collar protects the buyer against you buying unprofitable revenue, while preventing them from stripping away your payout through back-office overhead allocations.

In the definitive purchase agreement, define the revenue base with surgical precision. Exclude acquisitions the buyer makes during the earnout period, define standard pricing floors, and require the buyer to provide standard operating covenants. These covenants must obligate them to maintain historical sales budgets, staff key operational seats identified on your Accountability Chart, and run consistent marketing spend.

Additionally, establish that any voluntary operational decision made by the buyer that disrupts delivery, such as terminating key account managers or forcing an unproven enterprise resource planning platform, results in an immediate, full acceleration of the earnout payout. If the buyer controls the operational lever, they must bear the financial consequences of operational disruption.

Category: Valuation & Deal Structure

← All questions