tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

Several metrics on our leadership team Scorecard have been comfortably green for over eighteen months. How do we determine whether to keep tracking them or replace them with new operational indicators?

Your leadership team Scorecard has a strict limit of 5 to 15 numbers. Every cell is prime real estate. If a metric has been green for eighteen straight months, it is no longer providing diagnostic value at the leadership level.

A chronically green metric means one of two things: the target is set so low that it requires zero executive attention, or the underlying process has become fully institutionalized into your company's muscle memory.

Follow this protocol during your next Quarterly Pulsing session:

First, test the metric's target. Is it set at a true operational standard, or is it an easy baseline that masks complacency? If pushing the target by ten percent creates legitimate operational rigor and drives business growth, raise the bar.

Second, if the metric is truly solved, graduate it off the leadership team Scorecard and push it down to a departmental scorecard. The department head still monitors it weekly in their departmental Level 10 Meeting™, but it no longer clutters executive bandwidth.

Third, replace that slot with a leading indicator for a current vulnerability, a major strategic initiative from your V/TO®, or a critical process handoff that is currently unstable.

The Scorecard is an operational pulse, not a museum of past achievements. When a number is permanently healthy, delegate its monitoring and use your leadership capacity to track what is currently broken or scaling.

Category: Scorecards & Data

← All questions