Our department heads want to use AI to monitor communication channels and draft quarterly performance reviews for their direct reports. What parts of our people management and Accountability Chart evaluations must strictly stay human?
Performance evaluation and team accountability must remain exclusively human. Outsourcing personal assessments to an automated tool destroys company culture and breaches the fundamental trust required to run an effective leadership team.
In EOS, we evaluate people using the People Analyzer, measuring core values alignment and GWC: whether an individual gets it, wants it, and has the capacity to do the job. Evaluating GWC requires emotional intelligence, direct observation, and nuanced judgment. An AI model parsing Slack messages or email metadata can quantify activity, but it cannot measure genuine intent, humility, or conative fit. Using an algorithm to rate human contribution treats employees like commodities and breeds immediate cynicism across the organization.
Managers may use AI to organize raw, human-recorded notes regarding objective milestone delivery, such as whether a quarterly Rock was completed on time or if measurable Scorecard numbers hit their targets. However, the synthesis of that performance data, the delivery of constructive feedback, and the determination of whether someone fits their seat on the Accountability Chart must be conducted face-to-face.
Disciplinary actions, career pathing, and offboarding decisions also demand direct human ownership. When leadership hides behind algorithmic evaluations, it signals an unwillingness to lead. Keep automation focused on backend operational tasks and leave the evaluation of human character strictly to your leadership team.
Category: AI-Powered Operations