A competitor approached us with an unsolicited letter of intent to buy our business. Should we negotiate with them privately or run a full auction process through an investment banker?
An unsolicited letter of intent is almost always an attempt by an experienced buyer to acquire your company before you discover what it is truly worth on the open market. Negotiating with a single suitor puts you at an immediate, severe disadvantage.
When you deal with only one buyer, you have no leverage. You do not know if their valuation multiple reflects the top of the market. More dangerously, once you sign an LOI with an exclusivity clause, that buyer controls the clock. During due diligence, they will uncover every minor imperfection in your operations and systematically re-trade, renegotiating the purchase price downward or shifting cash at close into contingent earnouts because they know you have no backup options.
A structured competitive process run by an M&A advisor or investment banker changes the entire dynamic. It forces multiple strategic and financial buyers to compete on price, deal structure, and closing speed. Even if you ultimately select the original competitor, their valuation and contract terms will be significantly better because they know they are bidding against rival firms.
Use an unsolicited offer as a wake-up call rather than an immediate transaction. Review your operational health. Look at your financial discipline, your management autonomy, and your documented Core Processes. If your foundation is not exit-ready, pause the conversation. Spend the time required to build an undeniable operational foundation using your EOS® tools, hire an advisor to package your value, and run a disciplined process that maximizes your net proceeds.
Category: Exit Planning