tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

Our Head of Marketing has been with us for seven years and fits our core values, but as we push past fifteen million dollars, she does not Get It or have the Capacity for enterprise demand generation. How do we transition a loyal cultural fit out of a leadership seat without losing them entirely?

This is a classic Right Person, Wrong Seat scenario. It is painful because the individual is a cultural rock, but keeping someone in a seat they cannot execute damages the entire company and creates frustration for the employee.

The first step is absolute transparency. Schedule a private conversation to review the five core roles of the modern marketing seat. Walk through your growth targets and show what enterprise demand generation requires in terms of automated pipeline architecture, capital allocation, and predictive analytics. Be direct: the company needs capabilities that exceed her current skill set.

Do not jump to termination if she truly lives your core values. Look at your lower-tier Accountability Chart. Many leaders who fail to GWC a strategic executive seat excel as specialized individual contributors. She may be an exceptional content producer, event coordinator, or internal brand champion.

Offer her a clearly defined seat on the chart that matches her authentic strengths, with measurable expectations and revised compensation reflecting that specific seat. Frame it cleanly: the seat has outgrown her, not her value as a human being.

Give her forty-eight hours to process the change. She must decide whether she Wants the revised seat without lingering bitterness. If she accepts, integrate her quickly. If she cannot accept a non-executive role, assist her with an amicable, dignified exit. Keeping her in a seat she cannot handle will drag down company valuation and eventually break the relationship anyway.

Category: Accountability Chart & Seats

← All questions