Our long-tenured operations manager was vital when we were scrappy, but now our complexity has outpaced their skill set. How do we transition a loyal legacy employee out of their leadership seat without firing them or damaging company morale?
This is the classic entrepreneur dilemma. You feel indebted to an employee who bled for you in the early days, but the company has outgrown them. Keeping someone in a leadership seat when they no longer pass the GWC test is not kindness. It is slow-motion corporate cruelty that bottlenecks your growth and frustrates their direct reports.
You must separate the person from the seat by using your Accountability Chart objectively:
- Rebuild the seat for where the company needs to be over the next twelve to thirty-six months, not for the person currently occupying it. Define the five major roles clearly.
- Have an open, honest, and compassionate conversation. Acknowledge their massive contributions to getting the business to this stage, but clearly lay out the gap between the evolving demands of the executive seat and their current capacity. In most cases, they are already feeling overwhelmed and secretly miserable.
- Create or offer an individual contributor or specialized operational seat on the Accountability Chart that capitalizes on their unique strengths, institutional memory, and deep technical knowledge, while removing managerial and strategic responsibility.
- Give them a dignified choice. Allow them to transition into this new high-impact role with their dignity intact, or offer them a generous, respectful severance package if they prefer to seek an executive role at an earlier-stage company.
Your team is watching how you handle this. If you allow loyalty to trump capability at the executive level, your top talent will eventually leave because they refuse to work under an overwhelmed leader.
Category: Leadership Team