tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

The buyer is proposing an all-or-nothing cliff earnout where we receive zero payout if we hit ninety-eight percent of our gross profit target in year two. How do we structure a linear sliding scale with catch-up provisions across multi-year earnouts to prevent an all-or-nothing forfeiture?

Cliff earnouts are designed to fail. An all-or-nothing earnout tied to achieving one hundred percent of a financial target hands the buyer every financial incentive to sandbag operations, defer revenue, or accelerate expenses to finish just beneath the threshold. Agreeing to a structure where missing your target by two percent forfeits one hundred percent of your payout is an unacceptable gamble.

You must replace cliff earnouts with a linear sliding scale paired with cumulative catch-up mechanics:
- Sliding scale collar: Establish a performance floor, typically eighty to eighty-five percent of the target, below which no earnout is paid. Between eighty percent and one hundred percent, the earnout pays out proportionally on a dollar-for-dollar or percentage basis. Hitting ninety-five percent of the goal yields ninety-five percent of the earnout tranche.
- Performance accelerators: Demand an upside multiplier if you exceed one hundred percent of the target. If you overdeliver, that surplus should carry a premium to compensate for the downside risk you accepted.
- Multi-year cumulative catch-up: Business cycles do not align cleanly with twelve-month calendar windows. If you miss the target in year one due to supply chain delays or buyer onboarding friction, but exceed the cumulative two-year target at the end of year two, the contract must require a full retroactive catch-up payment for the missed year one tranche.

Insist that the earnout metric is anchored to gross profit or net revenue rather than EBITDA. Gross profit removes corporate overhead allocations, interest, and post-closing administrative bloat over which you have zero control, ensuring you are rewarded strictly for the commercial performance you generate.

Category: Valuation & Deal Structure

← All questions