tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

We are at an impasse on valuation where the buyer will not budge past six times EBITDA, but our forward pipeline supports eight times. How do we structure a gross profit earnout that bridges the valuation gap without surrendering post-closing operational control?

When a buyer refuses to price future pipeline into the closing cash, an earnout is the standard financial bridge. Most earnouts fail because owners accept targets tied to net income or EBITDA. Post-closing EBITDA is easily manipulated by new corporate overhead allocations, inflated executive salaries, integrated software costs, and shifting operational priorities. If you agree to an earnout, anchor it strictly to revenue or gross profit.

Gross profit is the cleanest compromise. It protects the buyer from unprofitable revenue dumping while protecting you from corporate expense dumping. To keep the structure bulletproof, embed these core protections into the purchase agreement:

- Measurement clarity: Define gross profit precisely according to your historical accounting policies, explicitly listing what costs sit above the line and locking out corporate allocation fees.
- Operating covenants: The buyer must covenant to run the business in the ordinary course, maintain agreed sales budgets, and adequately staff the delivery seats on your Accountability Chart.
- Acceleration triggers: If the buyer sells the company, replaces your leadership team, discontinues your core product line, or materially breaches the operating covenants, the entire earnout must accelerate and pay out in full immediately.
- Dispute mechanics: Avoid court litigation. Mandate that earnout calculations be audited and finalized by an independent, mutually agreed CPA firm whose determination is binding.

Treat an earnout as deferred upside, not guaranteed closing consideration. If the buyer requires you to hit forward targets to unlock the premium multiple, you must retain the operational authority over the people, resources, and Rocks required to execute the plan.

Category: Valuation & Deal Structure

← All questions