We received an all-cash offer at six times EBITDA from a private equity firm and an eight-and-a-half times offer from a strategic competitor that is heavily weighted toward buyer stock and earnout milestones. How do we normalize these two term sheets to compare true economic value and execution risk?
Comparing a clean cash financial offer to a structured strategic bid using headline multiples alone is financial self-deception. An eight-and-a-half times multiple that pays forty percent in private stock and thirty percent in post-close earnouts carries vastly different risk than a six times all-cash deal. To find the real winner, you must build a probability-weighted net present value model for each term sheet.
Break both proposals into their distinct economic buckets:
- Cash at close: Apply a 1.0 discount factor. This is guaranteed capital with zero post-closing execution risk.
- Seller debt and promissory notes: Discount these payments by your required rate of return, adjusting upward for their subordination tier behind senior bank lenders.
- Earnout consideration: Apply a steep probability discount, typically forty to sixty percent, based on your ability to control the underlying operating metrics and the likelihood of post-merger integration friction.
- Rollover or buyer stock: Evaluate the buyer's capital structure. If you are taking equity in a privately held strategic company, examine their senior debt load, liquidation preferences, and historical dividend distributions. Value this paper on a secondary market basis, not at their arbitrary internal valuation.
Next, deduct transaction friction and tax implications. Strategic acquisitions often trigger lengthy regulatory reviews, cultural integration issues, and complex indemnification structures. Financial sponsors typically close faster with lower indemnity escrows. Once you normalize both offers to risk-adjusted cash equivalents at closing, you will often find that the lower headline multiple from the sponsor delivers more certainty, higher net cash, and zero post-close operational vulnerability.
Category: Valuation & Deal Structure