tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

We are weighing an all-cash offer from a private equity platform at 5.5x EBITDA against a strategic competitor offering 7.0x EBITDA that includes twenty-five percent buyer equity. How do we objectively evaluate the true risk-adjusted enterprise value between a clean financial sponsor exit and illiquid strategic equity?

Headline purchase price is a distraction; net proceeds and closing certainty are what matter. A 7.0x multiple loaded with twenty-five percent illiquid buyer equity often delivers less real value than a clean 5.5x all-cash deal once you adjust for post-closing risk and capital structure realities.

To evaluate the strategic buyer's equity component, look at their share class and debt stack. In most acquisitions, strategic buyers issue common shares while funding the cash portion with heavy debt. If their existing balance sheet carries high leverage, or if institutional investors hold senior preferred equity with compounding liquidation preferences, your twenty-five percent rollover sits at the absolute bottom of the waterfall. If the combined company underperforms, that equity can be wiped out completely.

Next, assess post-merger integration risk. Strategic buyers pay 7.0x because they model aggressive cost synergies, which usually means consolidating facilities, cutting staff, and migrating software. If their leadership team fumbles the integration, revenue will slip and enterprise margins will contract, shrinking the value of your shares.

Conversely, the private equity buyer offering 5.5x cash gives you absolute finality. You take your money off the table on day one with zero market, integration, or refinancing risk.

If you prefer the higher valuation of the strategic offer, negotiate protective terms for the equity portion. Demand parity with their most senior share class, a guaranteed board observation seat, and a put option that forces the company to repurchase your shares at fair market value if they do not execute a liquidity event within four years. If they refuse to provide structural downside protection, the clean cash exit at 5.5x is the mathematically superior risk-adjusted deal.

Category: Valuation & Deal Structure

← All questions