We are quietly paying expensive outside consultants to do the high-level work our loyal, long-tenured VP of Finance cannot handle, effectively paying double for the seat. How do we stop subsidizing a loyalty gap and restructure the role cleanly?
Subsidizing an underperforming leader with outside consultants is an expensive form of avoidance. You are paying double for a single function just to dodge an uncomfortable conversation, while signaling to the rest of the leadership team that historical tenure exempts executives from accountability.
Evaluate the situation through the GWC framework. An early executive may Get it and Want it, but they lack the Capacity to handle complex financial modeling, capital allocation, or enterprise compliance. Capacity is not just time; it is technical skill, cognitive capacity, and the experience needed for where the company will be in three years.
First, look at the Accountability Chart without names. Define the five essential roles required for your finance seat at your current scale. If those roles require advanced cash forecasting, debt structuring, and automated enterprise reporting, document them clearly.
Second, evaluate your incumbent against those five roles. If you must pay external advisors to do the heavy lifting because your internal leader cannot execute, that leader does not GWC the seat. Period.
Third, have a direct, unsentimental conversation. Present the reality of the seat. If the individual fits your Core Values, offer them a seat they truly GWC, such as Controller or Accounting Manager, with compensation adjusted to market for that role. If their ego cannot accept a step back or no suitable seat exists, part ways cleanly with a generous severance package honoring their service. Continuing to subsidize their limitations compromises your operational foundation and handicaps your valuation.
Category: Leadership Team