My leadership team members debate issues during our meetings, but after decisions are made, they explain the new policies to their departments with lukewarm commitment or subtle criticism. How do we stop these leadership cracks from turning into canyons across the company?
When an executive tells their department that they did not agree with a leadership team decision, they are engaging in destructive political self-preservation. That behavior destroys trust, fuels departmental cynicism, and fractures company culture. Cracks at the leadership table always appear as deep canyons to the front-line staff.
You must institute a non-negotiable rule of leadership: passionate debate behind closed doors, absolute solidarity in public. During the IDS process in your Level 10 Meeting, demand vigorous, unfiltered debate. Every leader has an obligation to push back, challenge assumptions, and lay their cards on the table. However, once the decision is reached, debate ends. The decision belongs to the entire leadership team, and every member must champion it as if it were their own idea.
Make this standard explicit by incorporating cascading messaging into your meeting rhythm. Reserve the final five minutes of every Level 10 Meeting for Conclude. Agree precisely on the three key messages that need to be communicated to the organization, who will deliver them, and the timeline.
If a department head goes rogue and signals discontent to their team, address it immediately in a one-on-one meeting. Inform them that second-guessing leadership decisions to subordinates is a direct violation of team health and executive accountability. If they cannot publicly align with collective leadership decisions, they cannot remain on the leadership team.
Category: Leadership Team