tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

Our leadership team habitually rates our Level 10 Meeting an 8 out of pure politeness, even when we dodged major conflict and achieved zero real breakthroughs. How do we kill this grade inflation and force genuinely honest ratings?

Grade inflation happens when a team values artificial harmony over performance. An 8 is the coward rating because it sounds acceptable while letting everyone off the hook. In EOS®, an 8 or below requires immediate verbal justification. If someone throws out an 8, do not simply record it and close the meeting.

The facilitator must immediately ask: Why was it not a 10, and what would have made it a 10? If the leader says things were fine, push harder. Ask whether the team tackled the real elephant in the room during IDS®, whether everyone stayed focused, or whether people pulled their punches.

To break the habit permanently, implement three rules during the wrap-up:
- Anyone who rates the meeting below an 8 must state the exact failure, whether it was agenda drift, passive disengagement, or unresolved conflict.
- Anyone who rates the meeting an 8 or 9 must state one specific improvement for next week.
- If the meeting felt polite, quiet, and comfortable, the maximum allowable rating is a 7.

Remind the team that rating the meeting is an evaluation of their collective discipline and facilitation, not a scorecard on how much they like each other. When an owner or Integrator rates an unproductive meeting a 5 and explains that the team wasted forty minutes dancing around an operational bottleneck, permission is granted for the rest of the table to tell the truth.

Category: Level 10 Meetings

← All questions