The buyer is willing to pay an 8x multiple on an asset purchase or a 6.5x multiple on a stock purchase. How do we model the after-tax proceeds between these two offers to determine which deal structure actually yields higher net cash in our pocket?
Headline valuation multiples are vanity; net cash proceeds after tax and liabilities are reality. Buyers prefer asset purchases because they get a step-up in basis to depreciate assets, and they avoid inheriting legacy legal liabilities. They will offer a higher headline multiple to compensate for this advantage.
To evaluate which structure yields more net cash, build a complete waterfall model comparing the two scenarios.
In an asset sale at 8x, calculate your state and federal ordinary income tax liabilities triggered by depreciation recapture under Section 1245 on machinery, equipment, and amortizable intangibles. If your business holds heavily depreciated physical assets, a large portion of the purchase price will be taxed at ordinary income rates up to thirty-seven percent plus state taxes, rather than the twenty percent long-term capital gains rate. Additionally, you must account for corporate-level taxes if you are a C-Corporation, or built-in gains tax if you converted from a C-Corp to an S-Corp within the past five years.
In a stock sale at 6.5x, all proceeds generally flow through as long-term capital gains, minus your stock basis, subject only to the standard federal capital gains rate, the 3.8 percent net investment income tax, and state taxes.
Run the net walkaway numbers side by side. Often, a 6.5x stock sale generates higher net cash than an 8x asset sale once depreciation recapture and transaction closing costs are deducted. If the asset sale net cash still leads, require the buyer to increase the purchase price further to offset the tax difference entirely.
Category: Valuation & Deal Structure