Our long-time Controller also manages our HR and payroll, but our rapid growth requires a dedicated Director of People Operations. She is fighting the split, claiming we are stripping her authority. How do we execute this seat division on the Accountability Chart?
Combining Finance and HR under one person is standard in early-stage businesses, but it becomes a major bottleneck as you scale beyond thirty employees. Finance is focused on margins, cash preservation, and fiscal control. Strategic People Operations is focused on recruiting, talent retention, culture, and performance development. When one person owns both, human resources usually degenerates into transactional payroll and benefits administration while cultural health and leadership development are neglected.
To resolve this without alienating your Controller, anchor the discussion in the EOS principle of structure before people. Do not start by discussing her job description. Take your leadership team through an exercise to map the ideal structure needed to hit your three-year goals. Show the organization that managing compliance, treasury, reporting, and cash flow is a full-time discipline requiring 100 percent of an executive's capacity.
Next to it, draw the distinct People Operations seat, with roles focused on recruiting, onboarding, LMA across departments, and culture retention. Once the structure is agreed upon, evaluate her against both seats using GWC. Almost universally, a skilled financial professional has neither the desire nor the behavioral capacity to drive human resource strategy.
Frame the transition as elevating her focus to pure financial leadership, removing low-leverage administrative burdens so she can master cash flow and financial diligence for your eventual exit.
Category: Accountability Chart & Seats