One of our earliest employees holds a critical leadership seat and has bled for this business, but their technical and analytical capabilities have fallen far behind what our growth requires. How do we separate personal loyalty from business reality?
Entrepreneurs often confuse personal loyalty to an individual with loyalty to the company's mission and team. When you keep a legacy employee in a leadership seat they can no longer execute, you are not being kind. You are penalizing high performers under them who must pick up the slack, and you are putting the entire company at risk.
Run an objective assessment using the People Analyzer®. Evaluate them against your Core Values and the three components of GWC™: do they Get it, do they Want it, and do they have the Capacity to do it? Long-tenured employees often get the culture and want to help, but they simply lack the capacity to operate at the scale, speed, or technical sophistication the current market demands.
Have a direct, compassionate, and transparent conversation outside your normal meetings. Acknowledge everything they have contributed to get the business to this stage. Be entirely direct about the operational requirements of the seat over the next three years. Explain that the seat has evolved beyond their skill set, and keeping them there is setting them up to fail.
Explore whether there is an alternative seat on the Accountability Chart where they can thrive, such as client relations, special projects, or training, where their institutional knowledge is an asset rather than a bottleneck. If no such seat exists, provide a generous, dignified severance package. Do not let sentimentality compromise enterprise execution.
Category: Leadership Team