We are negotiating an asset sale with a significant installment note under Section 453 to spread out our taxable gains over five years, but our CPA warned us about the depreciation recapture trap. How does Section 1245 recapture undermine an installment sale, and how do we negotiate the purchase price allocation to fix it?
Section 453 of the Internal Revenue Code allows sellers to defer capital gains recognition as installment payments are collected, but it contains an immediate tax trap for asset sales: depreciation recapture under Section 1245 and Section 1250 cannot be deferred. Every dollar of historical depreciation taken on machinery, equipment, furniture, and certain software must be recognized as ordinary income in the year of sale, regardless of whether you received zero cash at closing.
If a significant portion of your purchase price is allocated to fully depreciated personal property and you take back a large seller note, you could face a massive, immediate phantom tax bill on money you have not yet collected.
To neutralize this risk, negotiate the purchase price allocation upfront on IRS Form 8594 during the Letter of Intent (LOI) stage, not as an afterthought during definitive drafting. Buyers naturally want purchase price allocated to Class VI and Class VII equipment and tangible assets because it provides them with rapid Section 168(k) bonus depreciation deductions. Your objective is the opposite: allocate as much value as possible to Class VII intangibles, goodwill, and going-concern value, which qualify for genuine capital gains treatment eligible for full Section 453 installment deferral.
Furthermore, structure the cash consideration at closing to exceed, at a minimum, your entire first-year tax liability, including ordinary recapture taxes and state obligations. Alternatively, require the buyer to pay down the installment note with an accelerated year-one principal payment dedicated specifically to covering non-deferrable depreciation recapture liabilities.
Category: Valuation & Deal Structure