tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

Private equity suitors are offering a deal structure that requires us to roll over twenty percent of our equity into the new holding company for a second bite of the apple. How should an owner evaluate the real risks and operational control trade-offs of rolling equity versus walking away with an all-cash exit?

Private equity firms use rollover equity for two primary reasons: it reduces the upfront cash required to close the deal, and it forces the selling founder to keep financial skin in the game. Promoters pitch the second bite of the apple as an opportunity to generate massive wealth when the platform sells to a larger fund three to seven years later.

You must evaluate rollover equity objectively as speculative, non-liquid minority equity. Once you roll equity into the buyer's holding company, you forfeit operational control. You become a minority shareholder governed by their capital structure, their board, and their preferred share rights.

Evaluate the rollover proposal against these non-negotiable criteria:

- Price your cash at closing to cover your ultimate wealth target. Your cash proceeds at close must independently fulfill your retirement and personal liquidity needs. Treat the rolled equity as high-risk capital rather than guaranteed proceeds.

- Audit the private equity firm's platform performance history. Investigate their prior funds: Have they consistently delivered on their projected multiples at exit? How heavily do they leverage their portfolio assets with high-interest institutional debt?

- Review the legal classes of shares in the holding entity. Ensure your rolled equity is pari passu (equal footing) with the sponsor's equity, rather than subordinated beneath compounding preferred return hurdles that wipe out common equity in a down sale.

- Examine tag-along and drag-along covenants. Confirm that you have the right to sell your equity on identical terms when the sponsor exits.

Never accept rollover equity to artificially hit an inflated headline purchase price. Protect your baseline cash at close first.

Category: Exit Planning

← All questions