We have a VP of Operations who is 100 percent a Right Person on core values, but he clearly does not GWC the leadership seat. We have an open Project Manager seat below him where he would thrive. How do we execute a seat demotion on the Accountability Chart without causing him to quit or poison the team?
Demoting an executive is one of the hardest calls a leadership team will ever make, but leaving a Right Person in the Wrong Seat is far more damaging. It handicaps your operations, frustrates the team members below them who must compensate for their deficiencies, and eventually causes that leader to burn out.
To execute this transition successfully, you must handle it with speed, transparency, and structure:
- Separate the person from the seat. Remind them immediately that they are deeply valued and fit your culture completely. The issue is purely structural. The VP of Operations seat has outgrown their natural skill set, while the Project Manager seat aligns directly with what they love and do best.
- Frame it through GWC™. Walk through the five accountabilities of the VP seat and the five accountabilities of the Project Manager seat. Show them where the friction is occurring. When handled properly, many leaders experience immense relief because struggling in an executive seat is exhausting.
- Address compensation and ego directly. You cannot pay a project manager an executive salary, but you can create a fair compensation structure tied to performance. Give them space to consider the offer privately, but do not negotiate the seat requirements.
- Give them an honorable exit option. Some people cannot handle the loss of status within their peer group. If staying in a non-leadership seat will make them bitter, you must part ways cleanly. Never retain an employee in a lower seat if their wounded pride will create passive-aggressive toxicity in your Level 10 Meeting™ or hallway conversations.
Category: Accountability Chart & Seats