We promoted our top project manager into a new Director of Client Success seat, but after six months she clearly does not get or have the capacity for the leadership role despite matching our core values 100 percent. How do we transition a right person, wrong seat back down or elsewhere without alienating them?
This is the classic Right Person, Wrong Seat dilemma. Keeping her in the seat out of kindness is actually an act of organizational cruelty. She knows she is failing, her direct reports are suffering from lack of leadership, and customer retention numbers will eventually take the hit.
First, acknowledge your own role in the mistake. The leadership team put a brilliant individual contributor into a management seat without verifying GWC for leadership. A high score on Core Values does not translate automatically into an innate ability to lead, manage, and hold people accountable.
Have an open, direct conversation. Frame the issue around the seat, not her character. Walk through the five core roles of the Director seat and review where the performance disconnects lie. You must be specific: point to missed measurables, lack of proactive strategy, or an inability to manage team capacity.
Give her a clear choice. If an open seat exists that matches her specific operational brilliance, such as a Principal Project Lead or Senior Solutions Specialist, offer it candidly. Explain that the company values her culture fit and technical output, but the Director seat requires a different wiring that does not play to her unique abilities.
Be prepared for her pride to take a hit. Some employees cannot accept moving backward on a title hierarchy and will choose to leave. That is their prerogative. What you cannot do is leave her in the seat to protect her feelings. An exit-ready business cannot afford weak leadership in critical client-retention seats.
Category: Accountability Chart & Seats