tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

Our Customer Service Director lives and breathes our Core Values and has been with us since day one, but the business has scaled past her capabilities and she clearly lacks GWC for the seat. How do we handle this Right Person, Wrong Seat dilemma without destroying company culture?

This is a classic Right Person, Wrong Seat dilemma, and it is one of the most emotionally challenging calls an owner must make. A person who fits your Core Values ninety-nine percent of the time is cultural gold, but keeping them in a leadership seat they cannot handle actively damages customer retention, frustrates their direct reports, and drags down your bottom line.

Start by being ruthlessly honest using GWC. She gets it and wants it, but she lacks capacity. Capacity is not just time; it is the emotional, intellectual, and technical capability to drive the seat at your current scale. You cannot leave her in that seat hoping she will miraculously catch up while your customer metrics deteriorate.

Because she is the Right Person, your first step is to see if there is another true seat on your Accountability Chart where she has total GWC. That might mean moving her into key account management, internal training, or culture coordination. However, this new seat must be a legitimate operational need, not an invented title created to avoid an uncomfortable conversation.

If you have a true seat for her, make the move with transparency and dignity. If you do not have a seat that matches her current capability, you must part ways honorably. When you do, the rest of the company will watch how you treat her. Give her a generous severance and celebrate her contributions. What you cannot do is sacrifice the operational performance of an entire department out of loyalty to past performance.

Category: Accountability Chart & Seats

← All questions