tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

Two key leaders on my team have stopped trusting each other due to missed deadlines, defensive excuses, and failed handoffs. How do we repair broken trust between peers on the leadership team?

Operational trust breaks down when leaders make commitments they fail to keep and then offer defensive justifications. Over time, missed deadlines and poor handoffs create quiet resentment. Leaders stop asking each other for help, workarounds are created, and cross-functional execution grinds to a halt. You cannot ignore this dynamic and hope it fixes itself.

Repairing trust requires addressing both character and operational competence. Use the principles from Stephen M. R. Covey's The Speed of Trust to diagnose the breakdown. Most often on an executive team, trust issues stem from a lack of clarity, poor accountability, and unkept agreements rather than intentional malice.

Bring both leaders together and address the issue directly using the IDS® framework. Start by establishing the facts: identify the exact broken handoffs, dropped Rocks, or missed Scorecard numbers that created the friction. Strip away emotional accusations and focus on observable operational failures. Require both individuals to take extreme ownership of their part in the breakdown without making excuses.

Next, establish crystal-clear agreements on how cross-functional handoffs will occur moving forward. Define unambiguous milestones, precise deadlines, and direct communication protocols. Trust is rebuilt incrementally through consistent, predictable execution over time. If both leaders fulfill their revised commitments over consecutive quarters, trust returns. If one leader continues to make excuses and drop balls, you have an unresolvable seat problem that requires personnel action.

Category: Leadership Team

← All questions