Over the last six months, we replaced three of our five leadership team members due to performance issues, and the surviving legacy leaders are now anxious, suspicious, and waiting for the other shoe to drop. How do we reset team health and rebuild psychological safety after severe executive turnover?
When over half a leadership team is swapped out, the remaining members naturally go into self-preservation mode. They stop taking risks, hoard information, and watch their peers with suspicion. If you do not actively rebuild team health, your new hires will inherit a toxic, defensive culture.
Rebuilding safety does not come from speeches or trust falls. It comes from radical transparency, predictable operational rhythms, and vulnerability.
Start by holding an honest State of the Company session specifically for the leadership team. Acknowledge the upheaval directly. Explain why the previous seats required changes based on the Accountability Chart and Core Values, without disparaging the former executives. Confirm that the current seats represent the structure needed to hit your three-year picture.
Next, leverage your weekly Level 10 Meeting to build functional trust. Trust is built through consistency and vulnerability. Use the good news check-in at the start of every meeting to humanize team members. During the IDS portion of the agenda, encourage the new leaders to bring their real, messy operational problems to the table. When legacy leaders see newcomers asking for help without being penalized, defensive barriers drop.
Finally, dedicate time in your next quarterly offsite to personal histories and working styles. Run the team through conative and behavioral profiles like Kolbe or DiSC. Understanding how each peer instinctively takes action and processes information eliminates false assumptions about motives.
When executives realize that accountability is objective and based on Scorecards and Rocks rather than personal politics, psychological safety returns rapidly. Focus on predictable execution and clean communication, and the anxiety will subside.
Category: Leadership Team