We finally fired a high-performing but culturally toxic leader from our leadership team, but our remaining leaders are still guarded, tentative, and walking on eggshells. What concrete steps can we take to repair trust and restore healthy collaboration at the table?
Removing a toxic leader is necessary, but firing them does not automatically restore health. Long-term exposure to an aggressive, political, or unpredictable peer leaves cultural scar tissue. Your remaining executives have built defensive habits: withholding honest opinions, documenting everything out of self-protection, and avoiding conflict.
You must actively dismantle those defensive habits.
First, hold a clean-slate conversation during your next quarterly offsite. Do not spend hours disparaging the former employee, but openly acknowledge the dysfunction that was tolerated. As the owner or Integrator, take ownership of the fact that the behavior was allowed to persist for too long. Apologizing for the delay in taking action validates the team's past frustration and signals that the standards have permanently changed.
Second, re-contract how the team will interact moving forward. Revisit your core values and your team's operating rules. Explicitly define what healthy communication looks like in your Level 10 Meeting™ and quarterly planning sessions. Give every leader permission to call time-out if old defensive behaviors resurface.
Third, focus on shared quick wins. In your quarterly planning, set collaborative Rocks that require two or more departments to work closely together to achieve a specific operational milestone. Rebuilding trust requires shared positive experiences where leaders rely on each other and see commitments honored without hidden agendas.
Finally, be patient but vigilant. Trust takes months to rebuild after a prolonged toxic tenure. Keep the focus on radical candor, transparent Scorecards, and authentic IDS® sessions. When leaders realize that speaking their mind no longer carries personal risk, the psychological safety will return, and the team will accelerate.
Category: Leadership Team