tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

During the Conclude section of our Level 10 Meeting, everyone reflexively rates the meeting an 8 every single week and nobody gives actionable feedback to improve. How do we break this automatic rubber-stamping and use the meeting rating to sharpen our facilitation?

An automatic rating of 8 is the executive equivalent of saying 'it was fine.' It is comfortable, lazy, and prevents the meeting pulse from improving. Teams default to an 8 because giving a 7 requires an explanation, while giving a 9 or 10 feels excessive.

To break this habit, the facilitator must change how the rating is conducted. First, remind the room what an 8 actually means. An 8 means the meeting was acceptable, but twenty percent of the value was left on the table. When someone gives an 8, do not simply write it down and move on. Ask them directly: What specific adjustment would have made this meeting a 10?

Second, evaluate the meeting against the strict EOS Level 10 Meeting criteria:

- Did we start on time?
- Did we end on time?
- Did we maintain reporting discipline without storytelling?
- Did we prioritize the most critical issues first rather than cherry-picking easy ones?
- Did we identify root causes and assign clear To-Dos with single owners?

If the answer to any of those questions was no, the meeting was not an 8. It was a 6 or a 7. The facilitator must set the tone by rating the meeting honestly themselves. When the leader rates a sloppy meeting a 6 and explains that the team spent twenty minutes dancing around root causes during IDS, permission is granted for everyone else to stop rubber-stamping and start holding the meeting execution accountable.

Category: Level 10 Meetings

← All questions