tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

We have a two million dollar valuation gap between our asking price and the buyer's offer. When deciding between bridging that gap with an earnout, a seller note, or additional rollover equity, how should we rank these three instruments based on operational risk and capital recovery?

Valuation gaps are inevitable, but the instrument you choose to bridge the gap determines who bears the operational risk after closing.

Rank these three options from most secure to least secure:

First: The Seller Note. A seller promissory note is pure debt. It represents a legally binding obligation to pay a fixed principal amount with regular interest, regardless of how well or poorly the buyer operates the business post-close. You can secure it against assets, negotiate default interest rates, and establish clear repayment timelines. If you must bridge a gap, prioritize a seller note with a sensible interest rate and clear covenants.

Second: Rollover Equity. Rollover equity carries higher risk than debt because it sits at the bottom of the capital stack. However, if you are selling to a well-capitalized private equity firm with a proven platform track record, rolling equity allows you to participate in the second bite of the apple when the platform recapitalizes. The key is ensuring your rolled equity is structured on the exact same share class and terms as the sponsor equity.

Third: The Earnout. The earnout is the least desirable bridge instrument. It places one hundred percent of the execution risk back onto your shoulders, even though you no longer control the board, the capital budget, or daily hiring decisions. Earnouts frequently result in post-close disputes.

Only accept an earnout if it is tied to top-line gross revenue, contains clear operational resource covenants, and you are prepared to walk away with zero dollars from that portion of the purchase price.

Category: Valuation & Deal Structure

← All questions