tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

The private equity group buying us requires a twenty percent rollover equity stake into their new holding company. How do we value this equity and avoid getting wiped out down the road?

Private equity buyers require rollover equity to keep your incentives aligned with their investment horizon. They want you to share downside risk and help them achieve a second bite of the apple when they sell the platform in five to seven years. However, minority rollover equity carries massive governance and dilution risks if negotiated poorly.

First, demand identical class rights. Ensure your rollover equity sits in the exact same class of units as the sponsor's equity, known as pari passu. If the sponsor issues themselves preferred equity with an eight or ten percent compounding annual return while giving you common units, their preferred return will drain enterprise value, leaving your common equity worthless if the exit fails to exceed expectations.

Second, negotiate protective minority provisions. You must insist on tag-along rights, which force the sponsor to include your equity on the exact same terms if they sell the company. Simultaneously, negotiate reasonable limits on drag-along rights so they cannot force you into an unvetted transaction without a minimum guaranteed return.

Third, verify the capital structure above your equity. Review how much senior and subordinated debt the sponsor plans to place on the business. If the entity is over-leveraged, normal operational hiccups can eliminate your equity value entirely. Treat your rollover equity not as guaranteed purchase price consideration, but as an illiquid, high-risk co-investment alongside an institutional fund.

Category: Valuation & Deal Structure

← All questions