tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

A member of our leadership team is performing adequately for where the business is today, but our three-year growth targets will clearly require an executive with capabilities far beyond what this person can learn. How do we proactively manage this upcoming gap without demotivating them or waiting for an operational crisis?

Waiting for a loyal leader to hit their ceiling and fail publicly is an abdication of leadership. Most owners see the wall coming twelve to eighteen months in advance, but they delay acting because the person is currently hitting their numbers. By the time the crisis hits, the business suffers massive customer churn, broken systems, and an emergency executive search.

Start by separating the seat from the person. During your annual planning session, update your Accountability Chart to reflect the structure needed for your 3-Year Picture. Clearly define the five major roles for that seat as it will exist at scale. Often, the scale seat looks fundamentally different from the current seat, requiring advanced enterprise sales experience, complex supply chain engineering, or sophisticated financial modeling.

Next, have a proactive, transparent GWC conversation with the executive. Walk through the future seat roles together. Ask for their honest assessment: Do you truly want to lead a department of this scale and complexity, or does your passion lie in the tactical craft you are doing right now? Many leaders are secretly relieved to admit that the administrative and strategic burden of a massive department does not fit their wiring.

Lay out the options clearly. If they want to stretch, invest in an executive coach or targeted development, with a clear six-month checkpoint to evaluate growth. If the gap is insurmountable, collaborate on a planned transition. This might mean recruiting an experienced executive over them while carving out a high-value, specialized seat that keeps them engaged and respected. Handled proactively, leaders appreciate the honesty. Handled reactively, it ends in bitterness and an ugly firing.

Category: Leadership Team

← All questions