tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

We are building our first leadership team Scorecard and keep ending up with over thirty metrics because every department head wants their entire domain represented. How do we whittle this down to 5 to 15 numbers that actually give us an objective pulse on the business?

A Scorecard is not an operational dashboard or a comprehensive reporting package. It is an early warning system designed to tell you if the business is healthy while sitting on a remote beach with only a single sheet of paper. When teams end up with thirty numbers, they are confusing leadership visibility with departmental management.

To cut the list down, apply the Great Day or Lousy Day framework. Ask your leaders: If you were away for a week with no phone calls, what single number tells you that your department had a winning week? For sales, it is not ten pipeline stages; it is qualified conversations or first-time pitches. For operations, it is not fifty task metrics; it is on-time delivery percentage or open tickets past service level agreement.

Every metric that does not make the cut belongs on a departmental scorecard, not the leadership Scorecard. The leadership team only tracks enterprise pulse numbers. Take every candidate metric and ask two questions: Does this number predict our downstream revenue, profit, or customer retention? And if this number is off track for two weeks in a row, does it warrant the entire leadership team spending time in IDS to solve it? If the answer to either question is no, push it down to a departmental scorecard or delete it entirely. Cut ruthlessly until you reach 5 to 15 numbers.

Category: Scorecards & Data

← All questions