tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

Our tax advisors suggest allocating thirty percent of the purchase price to personal goodwill to eliminate corporate-level double taxation, but the buyer is hesitant. How do we structure and support a personal goodwill allocation that satisfies both sides?

If your business is structured as a C corporation, or an S corporation subject to built-in gains tax, asset sales trigger punitive double taxation. Selling personal goodwill allows the shareholder to sell an asset owned directly by the individual, resulting in a single layer of federal capital gains tax while completely bypassing corporate-level taxes.

Buyers often hesitate because they want clear amortization deductions under Section 197 and fear the IRS will recharacterize the transaction, assessing penalties. To overcome their reluctance, you must provide rock-solid legal and operational substantiation.

Personal goodwill is legally defensible only if the owner has personal relationships, technical reputation, or specialized industry know-how that customers rely on, and critically, the owner is not bound by a pre-existing non-compete or employment agreement that previously transferred those rights to the corporate entity. If you never signed a covenant not to compete with your own company, that goodwill remains personal.

Obtain an independent, third-party purchase price allocation and valuation appraisal specifically quantifying personal goodwill versus enterprise goodwill prior to finalizing the purchase agreement.

Offer the buyer contractual safety. Draft the definitive agreement to include reciprocal tax indemnification language and confirm that personal goodwill remains fully amortizable by the buyer over fifteen years under Section 197, just like corporate goodwill.

In your EOS leadership transition, make sure your exit plan clearly defines the consulting agreement or non-compete you will sign with the buyer at closing. That closing non-compete is the exact instrument by which your personal goodwill is officially transferred to the acquiring entity.

Category: Valuation & Deal Structure

← All questions