tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

Our tax attorney recommends allocating a significant portion of our purchase price to personal goodwill rather than corporate goodwill to minimize state taxes and avoid double taxation. How do buyers view personal goodwill allocations during deal structuring, and what proof points are required?

Personal goodwill is a powerful tax planning strategy, particularly for owners operating as C-corporations or S-corporations subject to built-in gains tax. By proving that a substantial portion of enterprise value stems directly from the founder personal relationships, industry reputation, and proprietary trade knowledge rather than corporate assets, that value can be sold directly by the individual owner as a capital asset. This completely bypasses corporate-level entity taxation and avoids pass-through state taxes in certain jurisdictions.

While personal goodwill benefits the seller, buyers and their legal teams scrutinize it aggressively. The IRS frequently audits personal goodwill allocations under cases like Martin Ice Cream and Norwalk v. Commissioner. If the IRS reclassifies your personal goodwill as corporate goodwill, the owner faces severe back taxes, interest, and penalties. Buyers worry that if the IRS challenges the allocation, their Section 197 amortization deductions could be delayed or restructured.

To successfully execute a personal goodwill strategy in your deal structure, you must establish three non-negotiable proof points:

- Absence of restrictive covenants: You must not have an existing, pre-deal non-compete or employment agreement that previously assigned your personal relationships and trade knowledge to the corporate entity. If you already signed your rights away to the company, personal goodwill does not exist.
- Independent appraisal: You must commission an independent, third-party valuation firm to appraise the personal goodwill separately from corporate enterprise value before signing definitive agreements.
- Separate legal agreements: The founder must sign a separate personal goodwill purchase agreement, transferring relationships and agreeing to a direct post-closing non-compete and consulting arrangement directly with the buyer.

Work through this strategy during initial valuation modeling. If your leadership team and processes run completely through an EOS® Accountability Chart without you, personal goodwill is harder to defend, but your business commands a much higher corporate multiple.

Category: Valuation & Deal Structure

← All questions