tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

Whenever my leadership team tries to debate my strategic ideas, I get defensive and shut them down, which has created a culture where nobody challenges me in Level 10 Meetings. How do I personally rebuild vulnerability-based trust so my team will actually engage in healthy conflict?

Your business cannot scale beyond your personal capacity if your leadership team is terrified of your ego. When an owner reacts defensively to pushback, the leadership team learns very quickly that silence is safer than honesty. Artificial harmony takes over, decisions go unchallenged, and execution fails because nobody actually bought into your plan.

Rebuilding vulnerability-based trust requires you to go first. You cannot command people to be candid; you have to prove that candor is safe.

Take these concrete steps:

- Own the problem publicly. At your next quarterly offsite or Level 10 Meeting, put your own behavior at the top of the IDS list. State clearly that you have noticed your defensiveness, apologize for shutting down debate, and explain how it damages the company.
- Change your speaking order. As the Visionary or owner, you should always speak last during strategic debates. When an issue is framed, ask every other member of the leadership table for their raw assessment before you offer your perspective. If you speak first, you anchor the room and stifle dissent.
- Reward healthy pushback. When someone finally takes a risk and challenges your assumptions, thank them immediately in front of their peers. Even if you ultimately disagree with their conclusion, validate the courage it took to raise the point.
- Establish an issues-first mindset. Frame strategic disagreements around what is best for the business and the V/TO, not personal pride. Detach your self-worth from having the winning idea.

High-trust teams move fast because they do not waste time managing the owner's fragile emotions. If you want a team of true leaders, you must give up the need to always be right.

Category: Leadership Team

← All questions