We are running a six-month trial where two of our senior operations managers share the Head of Fulfillment seat while we decide which one to permanently promote. Measurables are slipping and our field techs are getting conflicting directives. Why does putting two names in one seat fail even as a temporary test, and how do we fix it immediately?
When two people are accountable for a single seat, nobody is accountable. Putting two names in one box instantly creates plausible deniability. When a measurable on the Scorecard drops or a Rock misses its milestone, each manager assumes the other had it covered, or they point fingers at differing operational philosophies.
Field technicians and supervisors feel this friction immediately. They will naturally gravitate toward the manager who gives them the answer they prefer, creating internal politics and operational whiplash. A six-month co-management trial does not test leadership capability. It tests political survival and paralyzes execution.
You must dismantle this shared arrangement this week. Pull the two managers into a room and IDS® the situation openly. The business requires one single leader to own fulfillment. Look at the five core roles of that seat and assess both candidates against your core values and GWC™. Who truly gets the strategic big picture of the seat? Who genuinely wants the burden of final accountability? Who has the intellectual and emotional capacity to lead the department at your target revenue?
Make the call. Put one name in the Head of Fulfillment seat. For the other manager, define their true seat below the department head, such as Lead Field Project Manager or Operations Quality Manager. If the candidate who was not chosen cannot accept reporting to their former peer, you have uncovered a core values or ego issue that was going to poison your culture anyway. Decisiveness creates clarity; sharing seats breeds chaos.
Category: Accountability Chart & Seats