tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

I am a non-technical owner running a commercial trade business, and our software vendors keep trying to upsell us on new AI add-ons. How do I evaluate whether an operational AI feature is legitimate or just expensive marketing theater?

Never evaluate artificial intelligence based on technical claims or algorithmic complexity. As an owner, your job is to evaluate operations, not code. When a vendor attempts to upsell an AI feature inside your enterprise resource planning system or field service software, demand answers to three non-technical questions.

First, which specific documented step in our core process does this feature replace? If the vendor cannot pinpoint the exact human action being eliminated, the feature is theater. Second, what is the failure rate of the model, and what does the fallback procedure look like when it hallucinates or misfires? Every automated system fails eventually; if resolving its mistakes requires an expensive technician spending an hour untangling bad data, your operational cost just increased. Third, how does the output integrate with our existing system of record without requiring manual re-entry?

Insist on testing the feature using twenty of your own historical, messy job records rather than their sanitized demonstration files. Watch your team interact with the tool. If the software does not eliminate low-value friction, protect your gross margins, or produce consistent results that support your Accountability Chart, decline the upgrade. You do not need to understand neural networks to recognize an expensive distraction.

Category: AI-Powered Operations

← All questions