tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

The buyer is insisting on an asset purchase to get a step-up in tax basis, but our CPA says the resulting tax hit leaves us with far less cash than a stock sale. How do we negotiate a tax gross-up payment into the purchase price to neutralize this asset sale discount?

Buyers prefer asset purchases because purchasing assets creates a stepped-up tax basis. Under Internal Revenue Code Section 197, this step-up allows the acquirer to depreciate physical equipment quickly and amortize acquired intangible assets and goodwill over fifteen years, generating significant future cash tax savings. For an owner operating as an S-corporation or LLC, however, an asset sale can trigger substantial ordinary income tax rates on depreciation recapture and inventory, severely reducing your net cash proceeds relative to a capital-gains-focused stock sale.

You should never concede an asset structure without capturing your share of the value created by that tax shield. First, have your M&A tax advisor model the exact net cash proceeds of both options: a straight stock purchase versus an asset purchase. Quantify the tax differential down to the exact dollar amount. Concurrently, have your team estimate the present value of the cash tax savings the buyer will capture through their fifteen-year amortization schedule.

Present this analysis transparently to the buyer. Explain that while you understand the strategic utility of an asset purchase, you evaluated their offer based on the net proceeds of a stock transaction. Negotiate an explicit tax gross-up payment that increases the enterprise value to offset your excess tax liability, or propose a Section 338(h)(10) election where the legal structure remains a stock sale but the transaction is treated as an asset sale for tax purposes, accompanied by a contractual gross-up clause. By framing the gross-up as sharing the economic value of the tax shield, you preserve your net proceeds without blowing up the deal.

Category: Valuation & Deal Structure

← All questions