tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

The private equity buyer is requiring us to roll over twenty percent of our equity into their new holding company platform. How do we ensure our rolled equity is valued on the exact same terms as their institutional capital rather than subordinated common shares?

Rollover equity is often pitched as an exciting opportunity to take a second bite of the apple when the private equity sponsor exits three to five years down the road. However, unless you negotiate the structural details aggressively, your rolled equity can easily be diluted, subordinated, or rendered worthless while the sponsor walks away with guaranteed returns.

To ensure parity with the institutional buyer, you must demand pari passu treatment. This means your rollover shares sit in the exact same equity class and share the same rights as the sponsor's primary investment. If the sponsor issues themselves preferred shares that carry an eight-percent cumulative dividend and liquidation preferences, your rollover equity must not be relegated to common units that only get paid after preferred hurdles are satisfied.

Key structural terms you must secure in the operating agreement include:
- Identical economic rights. Ensure your rollover equity receives distributions at the exact same time and pro-rata basis as the sponsor's equity.
- Robust tag-along rights. If the sponsor sells their controlling interest, you must have the contractual right to sell your shares at the identical valuation and terms.
- Protections against management fee drag. Private equity sponsors frequently charge portfolio companies monitoring fees or transaction advisory fees that reduce operating profits before equity distributions. Insist on caps or offsets on these fees.
- Preemptive rights to prevent dilution. If the platform raises additional capital in future funding rounds, you must have the right to participate to preserve your ownership percentage.

Rollover equity should only be accepted if you trust the sponsor's operational playbook and maintain full structural transparency into post-close governance.

Category: Valuation & Deal Structure

← All questions