tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

A private equity firm wants us to roll twenty percent of our equity into their new platform entity, but their standard deal terms issue common units subordinate to their preferred units with an eight percent hurdle. How do we negotiate our rollover terms so we do not end up with worthless paper if their debt-heavy growth plan stumbles?

Rolling equity into a private equity platform is sold to founders as taking a second bite of the apple. In practice, if you take common units while the sponsor takes preferred equity with an eight percent compounding annual hurdle, your rollover equity can be completely wiped out even if the business grows and sells for a higher enterprise value down the road.

In that structure, the sponsor collects their original capital plus their compounding eight percent return before common equity receives a single dollar. If the sponsor loads the business with senior debt and growth is merely modest, the preferred return and senior interest absorb all equity value, reducing your twenty percent rollover to zero.

Your mandate during Letter of Intent negotiations is to demand parity. Insist that your rollover equity is invested on a pari passu basis into the exact same security and share class held by the private equity fund, on identical economic terms. If the sponsor insists on holding preferred equity, your rollover must be issued as preferred equity with the exact same liquidation preference and dividend rate.

Beyond share class, secure mandatory tag-along rights so you can sell your shares alongside the sponsor on identical terms during their exit. Block drag-along provisions unless the transaction yields a specified minimum return on your rollover shares. Finally, require quarterly financial delivery and information rights identical to institutional board members so you can track how the platform is performing rather than waiting blindly for a secondary sale announcement.

Category: Valuation & Deal Structure

← All questions