tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

The private equity buyer is requiring us to roll twenty percent of our equity into their new holding company, but they are issuing us common units while their institutional fund takes preferred equity with an eight percent accruing dividend. How do we negotiate pari passu rollover equity so our payout is not wiped out?

Rolling equity into a subordinated common unit class behind a private equity firm's preferred equity is a major structural trap. If the sponsor holds preferred equity carrying an eight percent compounding dividend, that hurdle must be paid in full on exit before your common units receive a single dollar. If the business hits a market downturn or performs moderately, their preferred return eats up your entire equity value.

Insist on a pari passu rollover structure. This means your rollover equity sits in the exact same legal class of security, on identical terms, alongside the institutional investor's cash equity. If they receive preferred stock with an eight percent coupon, your rolled proceeds must be issued as the identical preferred instrument with the identical coupon, voting rights, and liquidation preference.

If the sponsor refuses due to fund structuring rules, negotiate a blended unit approach or demand a higher headline valuation to compensate for the structural subordination. Another alternative is securing catch-up distributions or common equity warrants that grant you bonus upside if the sponsor hits their base return targets.

Ensure you secure tag-along rights, information rights, and drag-along protections with minimum valuation floors. If the buyer can drag your units into a future sale that only satisfies their preferred return while wiping out common equity, your rollover paper is worthless. Never accept second-class equity in a recapitalization; demand institutional parity as a condition of your reinvestment.

Category: Valuation & Deal Structure

← All questions