tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

The buyer insists on structuring our transaction as an asset purchase to get a tax step-up in basis, but our tax CPA says this will cost us millions compared to a stock sale. How do we negotiate the valuation difference when a buyer demands an asset sale?

Buyers prefer asset sales because it allows them to step up the tax basis of your assets to fair market value and depreciate them over time, while simultaneously shielding them from unknown historical liabilities. For you as the seller, especially if you operate as an S-corporation or LLC with significant equipment or inventory, an asset sale triggers severe tax consequences through depreciation recapture and ordinary income rates instead of long-term capital gains.

You cannot evaluate an offer based on gross purchase price; you must evaluate it on net cash after taxes. When a buyer demands an asset sale, your response should be analytical, not emotional. Have your transaction CPA calculate the exact net tax leakage between a pure stock sale and the proposed asset structure.

Take that dollar delta to the negotiating table and insist on one of two structural remedies. The first is a purchase price gross-up, where the buyer increases the cash consideration to make you whole on an after-tax basis. Since the buyer receives a future tax shield through Section 197 amortization of intangible assets, they can often afford to fund this difference out of their future tax savings.

The second option is a joint election under Section 338(h)(10) or Section 336(e). This treats the transaction as an asset sale for federal income tax purposes while maintaining the legal form of a stock sale, which simplifies contract assignments and licenses. In either scenario, specify the purchase price allocation across asset classes in the Letter of Intent itself. Leaving asset allocation to post-LOI drafting invites costly disputes right before closing.

Category: Valuation & Deal Structure

← All questions