tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

One of our executives is sharp and delivers great numbers, but during our Level 10 Meetings they attack peers aggressively under the guise of open and honest debate. How do we preserve healthy conflict without letting one leader destroy psychological safety?

There is a massive distinction between unfiltered conflict around ideas and aggressive personal attacks aimed at dominating an argument. When an executive crosses that boundary, they are not demonstrating vulnerability-based trust; they are displaying high self-orientation, which damages the entire leadership team.

Cracks at the leadership level appear as canyons to the rest of the company. If other leaders feel bullied during IDS®, they will stop bringing critical issues to the table. They will choose artificial harmony and silent compliance, leaving serious operational landmines unresolved.

Take control of this situation through direct intervention:

First, address the behavior in real time during the Level 10 Meeting™. The Integrator must step in the moment debate turns personal, sarcastic, or dismissive. Remind the room that the team attacks the issue, never the person. If an executive interrupts, mocks, or belittles a peer, halt the discussion and re-establish the standard immediately.

Second, conduct a direct one-on-one session. Use your Core Values to demonstrate exactly how their delivery damages team cohesion. Provide specific examples of statements they made and explain the chilling effect those comments had on the rest of the team.

Third, set an explicit operational standard. Make it clear that exceptional technical output does not grant anyone immunity from being a healthy, functional team member. If they want to retain their seat at the leadership table, they must challenge operational issues rigorously while showing genuine respect for their colleagues. If they refuse to adapt their communication style, their numbers do not justify the organizational damage they leave in their wake.

Category: Leadership Team

← All questions