One of our leadership team members is brilliant at their functional role but constantly shows up late, skips company-wide rituals, and acts as though the rules do not apply to them. How do we address a high-performing prima donna who is eroding leadership team cohesion?
A high performer who violates your Core Values or team standards is not an asset; they are an organizational tax. When you tolerate exceptional results paired with toxic behavior, you signal to the entire company that performance excuses character.
Address the behavior immediately in your next one-on-one session. Do not soften the message or bury it under compliments about their functional production. Pull out your Core Values and the leadership team operating rules. Point to the specific behaviors: arriving late, dismissing Level 10 Meeting preparation, or ignoring operational standards.
Explain that technical brilliance does not exempt anyone from being a functional team player. For an executive seat, adhering to the culture and modeling accountability is half the job description. If they do not live the values, they do not GWC the seat.
Give them a definitive timeline to change, typically thirty days. Measure specific behavioral milestones, not intentions. If they scoff, become defensive, or claim their numbers make them untouchable, you have your answer. Transition them out. The relief across your leadership team and the rest of the company will immediately outweigh the temporary loss of their technical output.
Category: Leadership Team