tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

A founding employee on our leadership team has been with us for fifteen years and works tirelessly, but their outdated management style is causing high turnover among their direct reports. How do we separate historical loyalty from actual capability when making tough seat decisions?

Loyalty to an individual cannot take precedence over loyalty to the mission of the company. When an owner protects a loyal leader who lacks the capability to lead their seat, the entire organization pays the price through turnover, stalled growth, and lost enterprise value.

Evaluate this leader using the People Analyzer® and the GWC™ framework. Ask yourself three brutal questions: Do they get it? Do they want it? Do they have the capacity to do it?

Getting it means an innate, intuitive understanding of what modern leadership looks like in their seat. Wanting it means genuine passion to do the job, not just clinging to title and compensation. Capacity means having the emotional intelligence, skills, and time to manage people effectively as the company scales.

If their direct reports are quitting, this leader lacks the capacity for their seat. They might fit your core values, but they do not GWC the role. Keeping them in an executive seat sends a message that tenure matters more than competence. High performers under them will not stick around to watch you tolerate mediocrity.

Sit down with the leader for an honest conversation. Acknowledge their historical contributions and express genuine gratitude for the foundation they helped build. However, explain clearly that the requirements of the seat have outgrown their current capacity.

Offer them two paths. In some cases, a loyal veteran can transition into an individual contributor seat, a specialized advisory role, or a project-based position that leverages their historical knowledge without managing people. If no such seat exists on your Accountability Chart, or if their ego cannot accept a step back, you must help them transition out of the business with dignity and a fair severance. Your business cannot scale on nostalgia.

Category: Leadership Team

← All questions