We promoted our most loyal, long-standing department manager to the leadership team because they earned it through years of service, but they cannot think strategically and are drowning in executive discussions. How do we correct this promotion without losing them entirely?
You made the classic entrepreneurial error of treating a leadership seat as a loyalty reward. A seat on the leadership team exists to run and grow the enterprise, not to validate past contributions.
Start with the Accountability Chart. Look at the five major roles defined for that seat. Does this person genuinely get it, want it, and have the capacity to do it (GWC)? Usually, long-tenured managers get the company culture and want the prestige, but lack the capacity to operate at the strategic altitude required for an executive seat.
Have an honest, private conversation. Do not blindside them in a group setting. Explain that the company has evolved to a scale where the leadership seat requires enterprise-level strategic planning that does not match their unique ability. Be clear that keeping them in a role where they drown is unfair to them and damaging to the business.
Redesign a seat below the leadership table that leverages their actual strengths, such as managing day-to-day execution or client relationships. Keep their compensation whole if the business can afford it, framing it as recognition for their specialized value. If they choose to leave because their ego cannot accept stepping back, let them walk. Preserving their pride at the expense of executive effectiveness will paralyze your business.
Category: Leadership Team