tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

My chief operating officer was my third employee twelve years ago and has immense institutional loyalty, but the business has completely outgrown their capabilities and our growth is stalling. How do I handle this loyalty versus capability dilemma without destroying company culture?

This is one of the most painful decisions an entrepreneur faces, but loyalty cannot become a suicide pact for the company. Your company has grown, and the complexity of the seat has evolved. Keeping someone in a seat they can no longer handle does not honor their loyalty; it sets them up to fail, burns them out, and creates resentment across the rest of the leadership team.

Evaluate the situation using the EOS People Analyzer and the GWC framework: does this leader Get it, Want it, and have the Capacity to do it? In most legacy situations, the leader Gets it and Wants it, but they lack the Capacity to operate at the scale, speed, or technical sophistication the business now demands.

You have three practical choices:
- Redefine the Accountability Chart to carve out a specialized seat that matches their unique genius and historic institutional knowledge, while bringing in a leader who has genuine Capacity for the larger operational seat.
- Move them into an individual contributor or advisory role where their loyalty is celebrated without bottlenecking company execution.
- Transition them out of the business with deep generosity, respect, and severance.

The one choice you cannot make is leaving them in a seat where they are drowning. Your culture is defined by the performance and behaviors you tolerate. When other high performers see you protecting underperformance out of sentimentality, you lose your best talent.

Category: Leadership Team

← All questions