tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

Our first employee has been with us for twelve years and lives our core values completely, but our company has outgrown them and they no longer have the capacity to lead their department. How do we handle this Right Person, Wrong Seat situation without demoralizing our team?

This is a textbook Right Person, Wrong Seat dilemma. It is one of the most painful decisions an owner faces, especially when the individual has been loyal since day one and personifies every core value on your V/TO. However, keeping someone in a seat where they lack capacity guarantees execution failure, frustrates the rest of the team, and limits the company growth that everyone depends on.

First, confirm the diagnosis using GWC. They clearly get it and want it, but the business has grown in scale or complexity beyond their mental, physical, or emotional capacity. Be totally candid with them in a private conversation. Do not ambush them; use the People Analyzer to anchor the discussion in objective business reality. Explain that while their commitment and values are unimpeachable, the seat now requires capabilities that are not their natural strengths.

Next, explore whether there is a true seat elsewhere on the Accountability Chart where they can thrive. Loyal veterans often make incredible individual contributors, customer relationship leads, or specialized project managers because they understand company history and culture. Stripping management responsibilities off someone who hates managing people is often a massive relief for them.

If a suitable seat does not exist, you must execute a graceful, honorable transition out of the business. Provide a generous severance, celebrate their twelve years of contributions publicly, and treat them with absolute dignity. What you cannot do is leave them in a leadership seat they cannot handle. Doing so signals to the entire company that loyalty trumps performance.

Category: Accountability Chart & Seats

← All questions