tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

Our Head of Finance was solid as we grew to five million, but as we push past fifteen million, they are drowning in basic reconciliations and cannot deliver forward-looking financial modeling. How do we objectively determine if this is a training issue or if they have hit their ceiling?

When a company scales from five to fifteen million, the operational complexity does not double, it squares. A seat that once required clean transactional bookkeeping now requires capital allocation, cash conversion cycle management, automated financial reporting, and predictive unit economics. You are feeling the pain of an executive who was built for the company you were, not the company you are becoming.

To evaluate this objectively, separate loyalty from capability using the Accountability Chart. Look at the five core roles of the finance seat as it must exist today. Compare that list to their actual output over the last two quarters. Are their Scorecard measurables consistently red? Are their Rocks constantly rolling over from quarter to quarter? If the answer is yes, evaluate their GWC.

Most owners confuse wanting with getting and capacity. Your financial head may deeply want the job, but they no longer get the strategic altitude required to build automated reporting or talk to institutional lenders. They simply lack the capacity to operate at this new scale.

Have a direct conversation during your next quarterly check-in. Walk through the five roles of the seat and show them where the gap sits. Give them thirty days to present a realistic plan to automate low-level work or level up their skills. If they cannot demonstrate immediate traction, you must make a seat change. Keeping someone in a leadership seat who has hit their ceiling holds the entire company back and punishes the leaders who can scale.

Category: Leadership Team

← All questions