tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

Every time a number is off track on our weekly Scorecard, the owner immediately launches into a long explanation or defense, dragging the meeting into the weeds. How do we keep the Scorecard review strictly reporting?

A Scorecard is an objective pulse of your company's vital signs. It is designed to highlight reality, not to serve as a platform for excuses, justifications, or operational storytelling. The moment someone starts explaining why a metric missed its target, your Scorecard review has devolved into premature problem-solving.

The rule for the Scorecard segment is absolute: report the number and state whether it is on track or off track. That takes three seconds per row. The owner of the metric should never speak more than five words: Revenue was ninety thousand, off track.

If the number is off track, the facilitator asks one question: Does this drop to the list? If the metric has been off for multiple weeks or signals an operational breakdown, the owner or any team member says yes. The scribe drops it down to the Issues List with a short label. You do not ask why it happened, you do not ask what the team is doing about it, and you do not allow a story.

Leaders launch into defenses out of fear of judgment. The facilitator must establish that a red number on a Scorecard is not a personal failure; it is simply data pointing to an issue that needs solving. Tell the team: We are not here to judge you; we are here to see reality. We will solve the root cause in IDS. Move to the next metric without pause.

Category: Level 10 Meetings

← All questions