Our second-in-command wants to buy the company, but they have zero liquid capital. How do we evaluate an internal management buyout versus an outside sale without carrying all the financing risk ourselves?
An internal sale sounds attractive because it protects culture and feels loyal, but when a successor has no capital, the owner almost always ends up acting as the commercial bank through an enormous seller note. If you finance eighty percent of the purchase price, you have not actually exited. You have traded operational stress for balance sheet risk, and your retirement depends entirely on someone else running your asset.
To evaluate an internal management buyout objectively, separate sentiment from capital structure. Require the successor to bring real equity or institutional debt to the table. An internal buyer can explore an SBA 7(a) loan, which allows up to five million dollars in government-backed financing with as little as ten percent equity down, or partner with a private equity search fund to supply mezzanine financing.
If the successor cannot qualify for third-party financing, an outside sale to a strategic or private equity buyer is usually the superior route to achieve true financial liquidity. An outside buyer provides verified capital, allows you to cash out clean at close, and often retains your internal successor to run daily operations, which can actually give that leader the growth runway they desire.
Look at your V/TO and determine your non-negotiables. If your primary objective is absolute financial freedom and eliminating personal risk, you cannot carry a massive seller note. If your priority is local legacy at any cost, an earn-out or gradual stock redemption may work, but you must accept the financial risk that comes with it.
Category: Exit Planning