tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

Our leadership team is frozen in analysis paralysis trying to select our first 5 to 15 Scorecard numbers, arguing endlessly about what to measure. What is the practical filtering method to pick our starting numbers without wasting weeks debating?

Leadership teams get stuck picking Scorecard numbers because they believe their initial selections must be permanent and mathematically perfect. They treat the exercise like chiseling stone instead of testing an instrument panel.

To break the deadlock, run the Great Day or Lousy Day test. Ask each seat on your Accountability Chart a single question: If you were stranded on a remote island with no phone or email, what three numbers would tell you whether your department had a great week or a lousy week?

Force every leader to write down their three numbers. Then apply three filtering rules:
- The number must be weekly. If you can only measure it monthly or quarterly, it belongs on your V/TO or in financial reviews, not on the weekly Scorecard.
- The number must be leading, not lagging. It should measure activity, volume, or speed, not the final financial outcome.
- The number must have a single owner who can directly influence the outcome through their seat.

Collect those metrics. You will have between nine and fifteen numbers across sales, marketing, operations, and finance. Put them on the Scorecard immediately and commit to running with them for eight weeks without editing the list.

Do not debate whether you picked the absolute best metrics. You will discover their real value through weekly repetition. After eight weeks, any number that always stays green without effort or fails to predict downstream trouble gets cut or replaced. Action creates clarity; endless debate creates delay.

Category: Scorecards & Data

← All questions